Asthma Burden in the Hospitalized Patients in North of Iran

Authors

1 Mazandaran University of Medical sciences, Sari, Iran

2 Mazandaran University of Medical sciences, Faculty of Medicine, Sari, Iran

Abstract

Introduction: Asthma is a chronic inflammatory airway disease. Genetic and environmental factors have been important role in the induction of asthma. It's estimated that asthma affect 2.7 to 35.4% of child (in average 13.4%) in Iran. The aims of this study to assess the costs of asthma patients admitted in Boali hospital in Sari in the north of Iran.
Patients and Methods: This descriptive study was carried out in asthma patients 1 to 20 years old that admitted in the Boali hospital in Sari from 2008 to2012. Out of 455 folders, 22 folders excluded because incomplete registrations.
Results: Out of 432 patients, 280 patients (64.81%) were male. 349 patients were 1-5 years old (80.78%). Average annual cost in our asthmatic patients was 1219064 Rials(Iran currency) ($ 121.9) per patient, 1183655 ($ 118.3) and 1284789($ 128.5) Rials per male and per female patient respectively.
Conclusions: Our study showed asthma disease has been significantly cost for patient, family

Keywords


Introduction:

Asthma is a chronic inflammatory respiratory disease affect all of ages predominantly in children (1). More than 300 million people in the world currently have asthma. With increasing of asthma prevalence from several decades ago, it is estimated that more than 100 million people involved by asthma in 2025. It has a high economic burden on patients, their family, and society and healthcare resources in different countries (1-3).More common clinical manifestations including cough, wheezing, and dyspnea due to airway bronchospasm, intraluminal secretion and hypertrophy with hyperplasia of epithelial cells and muscles. Asthma had significant morbidity and mortality all over the world (4-6).Although, exact etiology of disease is not known, but genetic and environmental factors have been included in the induction of disease (6-9).In addition, a series of household allergens such as mites can cause asthma attack in susceptible individuals. Also, drugs such as Aspirin, Indomethacin and other non steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs can cause expression of asthma in susceptible individuals (9, 10).
Is estimated that the disease affect 10-17% children, which in turn are created the high economic burden for society, especially in industrial societies (1,2).  About 1% of the budget of a country like America should be spent on treating asthmatic patients (11). Total average annual costs per asthmatic patients have variation in different countries according to the assessment of patients, the healthcare system, indirect costs and treatment of asthma (3, 7, 8). For example, the cost of annual treatment of asthma in America per patient is 640 dollars and in Sweden is 1315 dollars (11). Also the annual direct cost of asthma in Malaysia has been reported  $ 108 and in Hong Kong is  $1010 (12).

There has been obvious increase in the global prevalence, morbidity and mortality and even economic burden of asthma since the 1960s that specially in children was sharper than adult population (13).In the middle east region about 20 million children suffer from this disease. Although asthma is more common in developed countries, its prevalence is becoming increasingly common in underdeveloped countries. It seems that main reason is increased urbanization in these countries (14).

Knowledge about burden of asthma is needed for health planner for making specific plans for prevention and treatment.

The aim of this study estimate of different cost of asthmatic patients admitted in a general university educational hospital in capital of mazandaran provenance in the north of Iran from 2006-2010.


Patients and Methods:

This descriptive study was carried out in asthmatic patients with 1 to 20 years old ages admitted in the children wards in Boali hospital in Sari (the capital of Mazandaran province) in the north of Iran from 2008 to 2012. Out of 455 patient’s folders, 22 folders excluded because they had been incomplete data. At last, 432 folders were evaluated.we evaluate demographic data  such as age, sex  and  other data including; number of hospitalization days, family history of asthma, a history of allergies or chronic medical illnesses, previous history of hospitalization due to asthma, a history of drug use, history of admission in PICU, hospitalizations and medical costs nursing and emergency services. Data recorded in the computer and were analyzed by SPSS (version 13) software. We analyzed our data with t-test and Anova statistical assay with significant validate when CI was less than 0.05%.
Results:

Out of the 432 asthmatic patients admitted in the hospital, 280 cases were male (64.81%) and 152  cases were female (35.18%).the  most patients in our study were between 1- 5 years old ages (80.78%) .Also 6-10 and 11-20 years old were 76 patients (17.59%) and 7 patients (1.61%) respectively (Table-1).

 133 patients (30.78%) had 2 days admission with future states; 3days (22.45%), 1day (16.20%) and 4 days (14.81%) respectively (Table-2).

153 patients (35.41%) had previous history of hospitalization in general ward of hospital cause asthma attack but 279 patients (60.4%) didn’t. On the other hand these patients admitted first time in the hospital for asthma attack. 26 asthmatic patients (6.94%), admitted in the PICU because of severe asthma and 109 patients (25.23%) had a family history of asthma .79 patients (18.28%) were mentioned history of other medical illness (Table-3).

In our study more patients toked 4 drugs (32.17%) and the less common incidence includes; 3 drugs (28.24%), five drugs (18.51%) and 2 drugs (9.49%) (Table-4).

The average of cost for 1-5, 6-10 and 11-15 years old ages were 1273020, 1004236 and 1080483 respectively.
In this study, the overall mean cost of medical insurance and hospital were respectively, 518437($ 17.5) and 7050627($ 25) Rials , additively equals 1219064R .In male patients were 533240($ 17.8) and 650,415($ 25) Rials respectively and in female patients 533774($ 17) and 751015 ($ 25) Rials respectively. The average cost per patient for the nursing for medical insurance and hospital was 101,480 ($ 3) and 85,986($ 2.2) Rials respectively (Table-5).We explained that each 10000 Rials equals $1 (2008-2012).
Discussion:

Asthma burden is a serious concern for patient, family and government or private health managers because asthma is the most common chronic disorders in children. Asthma burden is different and including morbidity, mortality and impaired of quality of life (direct and indirect costs). The prevalence of asthma is different in the world. The   pooled prevalence of asthma in male, female and both is 4.3% (CI; 3.5 to 5.1%), 3.2% (CI; 2.5 to 3.9%), and 3.9% (CI; 3.2 to 4.7%), respectively in Iran (15). Totally prevalence of asthma in Iranian children estimated as 13.14% (95% CI: 9.97-16.30%)(16). In author`s study in this region showed 12% prevalence of asthma in elementary schools (17,18). Therefore, several millions of children in our country have asthma. The asthma healthcare cost is 1-2% total healthcare costs in developed countries (19). In Asia the prevalence of asthma is 1.5% in Nepal and 6.2% in Hong Kong (20).

Our patients were under 5 years old ages(77%), therefore , younger children were more predispose to get asthma attach and admit ion.Male patients were more common(65%)  then they have a more predispose to get asthma attach and more admission. The similar other study showed asthma prevalence is more common in male gender than female gender (1.5 to 2 times) (21). In China male to female ratio of asthma disease is 1.75:1(22) but in India the prevalence of asthma is in a range of 0.5 – 18 %( 23).

The most of our patients had a short time (less than 2 days) admission. With prescribe good action plan to patients or care keepers could to take low admission rate and short duration of admission. Fortunately, the most of our cases had a short time stay in hospital. This is the similar study in Brazil that fifty percent of patients remain in hospital for less than 2 days (24).

150 cases of our patients had previous history of admission (33%), well, it is important that more patients with asthma don`t have previous admission. Mild asthma could be at risk of attacks because, they use intermittent drug, only short acting beta agonist and even the stop drugs. Also, under diagnosis and family denied of asthma could be other reasons.

6.1% of our patients had history of admission in PICU. Although this is low incidence but it has higher cost compare to patient that admitted in general ward. Also, these patients have more morbidity and mortality. In Brazil study showed PICU admission of asthma attacks was 7.3% of all admissions (25).  

Family history allergic diseases including asthma, allergic rhinitis, atopic dermatitis and urticarial was positive in 24percent (n=108) of our patients. Then, often of patients did not have family history and this is not nessecery for diagnosis of asthma.

76 of our patients had other disorders such as sinusitis, allergic rhinitis that induce increases cost.

More common of patients in our study received 3 or 4 drugs that they have more financial burden. The top 4 drugs used in our study were vetolin (short acting beta agonist), Hydrocortisone, Atrovent and nasal washing with sodium chloride.

Current guidelines are important because doing it could be useless more drugs and induce decrease cost. Available a good emergency department with enough equipment could be treat asthma attacks and this reduced future admition. Air pollution one the important risk factor for induces attack asthma then government managers need to reduce air pollution and make a clear air.

Our study showed that physician fee (428280R, $42.82), drug cost (242186R, $24.21)   and consultants (214339R, $21.43)   were containing more cost. The cost of nursing, x-ray and laboratory tests were less common. Physician fee, consultants and nursing costs was not significant differences between two genders but drug fee was more common in male gender. Laboratory and x-ray costs were more common in female group.

Total average cost of admission for a female and male patients were 1284789 and 1183655 Rials respectively.  Average cost In Australian family for a child with asthma was $212.48. in this country  the mean cost for hospitalized asthmatic patients was $884.34  annualy.(26).

 In comparison, adult asthma has a high impact burden on direct and indirect cost such as low reproducibility, abstinent at work, loss of job. Annually cost of adult asthma was 1907 dollars (2008 dollars) in USA (27).

 The average cost was more expensive in 1-5 years old cause to laboratory, consultants and admission costs and there is significant difference between less than 5 years old and older ages. The similar results were seen in other study (28). And in Brazil the highest rates are recorded in children under 5 years of age (15% of all admissions) (29). In verse, in Peru mainly asthmatic children are aged 5–9 years (30).

 Between two groups with previous admission history or not, we showed that average cost in previous admission group was 1155723 R, ($115.55) but in other group was 1248740R ($124.87).  Therefore, previous history due to more knowledge, early diagnosis and early intervention with appropriate treatment cause less cost.

Only 26 cases of our study were in PICU but the average cost was more expensive (2 times) than general wards, 2510962 ($251)     and 1146175 R ($114.61)   respectively. Therefore, increase knowledge, early diagnosis, early treatment could decrease admission especially PICU admission. In other study showed that uncontrolled or partially controlled asthma had more cost with 50% indirect cost (31).

Family history of allergic disorders was positive in 106 patients showed atopic base. Cost in positive and negative family history of allergic disorders was 1265430($126.54)   and 1199472R ($119.9)   respectively. At results, it seems that atopic condition cause more expensive cost although there is not significant differences between two groups.

76 patients has other diseases such as rhinitis, sinusitis, otitis and GERD with

 Average cost 1462004R ($146) in contrast other group without other disease with 1163715R ($116.3).Added disorder due to addition drugs and slowly response to asthmatic drugs cause longer stay in hospital and more cost (P<0.05).

The average cost each patient in our study was 120 dollars but in other study the annual costs of treatment of hospitalization of asthma patients was $ 790(6). In New Zealand country, annual cost for asthmatic patient is high (US$ 2584) compared US$ 410 for others (32).  

 However, in India, the cost of treatment of an asthmatic patient was US$ 30 per month (33).

 Our study showed severe asthma(PICU patients) has more cost than less severe form, this is similar other studies that the cost of treatment based on disease severity is as follows: Annual treatment costs are about $ 1,336 in mild asthma, $ 2,407 in moderate asthma and$ 6,393 in severe forms. This is important point that in all levels of severity; indirect costs were twice as high as direct costs. Also at all severity, total direct annual costs in females were higher more than males. This is similar our study that showed more direct cost of female admission than male admission. Unfortunately, we could not estimate indirect burden of our patients.

Therefore, many of mild and moderate asthmatic patients could be treated by primary care physicians according to current guidelines then we could reduce cost of these patients.

The annual treatment cost of asthma in European countries is high. For example annual burden of asthma in France approximately estimated to be 1.5 billion euro and 2.7 billion euro in Germany (34). Total annual cost has been found to be more than 2.5 fold higher in uncontrolled or without access to healthcare in asthmatic patients (35). Again mentioned, unfortunately, there is not any statistics of annual cost of asthmatic patients in Iran. Therefore, we could not compare between my country with other countries. Annual cost of asthma patients in Iran may be higher, lower or equally than other countries.

Annual cost of asthmatic patients is different for a patient and for a country with other country. This is depended to local drug price, severity of asthma, buy drugs from other countries and prevalence of asthma. The prevalence of asthma among children based on diagnostic and differences in race and residency area is different from 4.4% in Asia to 13% of United States (13, 14). Average prevalence of asthma is 13.14% in Iran which is median in the world (16).

Asthma education in association with anti-inflammatory treatment has led to decreased asthma morbidity and reduced asthma-related costs (36).   

 Limitations of our study are: Firstly our study carried out on asthma patients and reliability of our study was based on recorded data on these folders, this is a retrospective study. Probability there is some under diagnosis or over diagnosis.  Secondly we didn’t reach the indirect cost of asthma because we evaluate folders of patients that didn’t include the indirect costs. At last, we could not evaluate other costs includes; physician visits and dugs cost (outpatient cares).

Nevertheless with these limitations, with high prevalence of asthma in Iran,  we need to education to patients (including; action plan, use of spacer for MDI sprays, use of oral steroid, need short acting beta agonist), physicians   especially primary care  keepers to  controls and suitable treatment of asthma  to prevent high economic burden, morbidity and mortality especially in severe cases.

Annual training program such as asthma congress or seminar in world asthma day for all health workers (physicians, nurses, family) could be effective for increase knowledge of this disease and then decrease attacks, admission and cost.

We suggest carry out more accurate studies in Iran for assessing the annual direct and indirect cost of asthma in children.

Table1:  distribution of age in our asthmatic patients admitted between 2006-2010

  Age(years old)                            number                                    percent

1-5                                                349                                                 80.78

6-10                                               76                                                   17.59                                                

11-15                                              6                                                   1.38

16-20                                              1                                                   0.23

Missing (exclude data)                     23                                                     5

Total                                              432                                                 100

Male                                              280                                                 64.81

Female                                          152                                                 35.18

 

Table 2: distribution of  duration of day`s admission in our asthmatic patients in 2006-2010

Days                                             number                                     percent

1                                                   70                                              16.20

2                                                  133                                             30.78

3                                                  97                                               22.45

4                                                  64                                               14.81

5                                                    27                                               6.25

6                                                   16                                                3.70

>6                                                 25                                                 5.78                                       

Total                                            432                                                  100

  Table3: distribution of previous history of admission, PICU admission, family history of allergic disorders, personal history of other diseases in our asthmatic patients in 2006-2010

            Previous history of admission                                      number                           percent            

Yes                                                               153                                35.41

No                                                                  279                              64.58

Total                                                               432                                 100

PICU  admission

Yes                                                                  30                                6.94

No                                                                   402                              93.05   

Total                                                               432                             100

Family history of   allergic disorders                   

Yes                                                                 109                          25.23

No                                                                    323                           74.76

Total                                                                 432                            100

Combined other disorders 

Yes                                                                     79                             18.28

No                                                                      353                            81.71

Total                                                                  432                               100

 

 Table 4: distribution of drug number application in our asthmatic patients in 2006-2010

Drug( number )                              number of patients used                     percent

1                                                                  3                                               0.69

2                                                                   41                                            9.49

3                                                                  122                                          28.24

4                                                                  139                                           32.17

5                                                                   80                                           18.51

6                                                                   32                                             7.40

>6                                                                15                                             3.47

Total                                                             432                                           100                     

 

Table 5: distribution of mean cost based on drug, x-ray, laboratory, physician, consultants and nursery in our asthmatic patients in 2006-2010

Objects                                                           mean cost

Drugs                                                                242030 R ($ 24.2)                                                       

X-ray                                                                    61012 R ( $ 6.1)

Laboratory tests                                                    49669 R ($ 2.9)

Physician                                                             528280 R ($ 52.8)

Consultants                                                          244339 R ($ 24.4)

Nursing                                                                  93734 R ($ 9.3)

Total                                                                  1219064 R ($ 121.9)

Male                                                                   1183655 R ($ 118.3)

Female                                                                1284789 R ($ 128.4)

 

 

 

 

1. Hedman J, Kaprio J,Poussa T,Nieminen MM. Prevalence of asthma ,aspirin intolerance, nasal polyposis and chronic obstructive pulmonary disease in a population-based study. Int J Epidemiol 1999; 28:717-722.

2. Hann DL, Beasley JW. Diagnosis and possible undiagnosed asthma: a wisconson research network study. J Farm Pract 1994; 38(4):373-379.

3. Tjard R, Bart P, Reiner P, Richard P, Hans T. Randomized controlled economic evaluation of asthma self-management in primary health care. American Journal of Respiratory and Critical Care Medicine 2002): 166: 8,: 1062-1072

4.  Bousquet  J,  Knani J, Dhivert H, Richard A,  Chicoye A, John E. Ware Jr, Michel FB. "Quality of life in asthma. I. Internal consistency and validity of the SF-36 questionnaire" American journal of respiratory and critical care medicine 149.2 Pt 1 1994.

5. Pearce N, Sunyer J, Cheng S, Chinn S, Björkstén B, Burr M,et al. Comparison of asthma prevalence in the ISAAC and the ECRHS. ISAAC Steering Committee and the European Community Respiratory Health Survey. International Study of Asthma and Allergies in Childhood. Eur Respir J. 2000 Sep;16(3):420-426.

6. Vervloet D., Williams A. E., Lloyd A., Clark T. J. H.Costs of managing asthma as defined by a derived Asthma Control TestTM score in seven European countries. Eur Respir Rev 2006; 15(98): 17-23.

7. Beasley R.The Burden of asthma with specific refrence to united states.  The J allergy 2002,

8. Riccioni G, D'Orazio N, Di Ilio C, Menna V, Guagnano MT, Della Vecchia R. Quality of Life and clinical symptoms in asthmatic subjects.  J Asthma. 2004 Feb;41(1):85-89.

9. Szczeklik A,  Gryglewski RJ,  Czerniawska-Mysik G, Pieton R .Asthmatic attacks induced in aspirin-sensitive patients by diclofenac and naproxen. Br Med J. 1977  23; 2(6081): 231–232.

10. Sabry EY. The prevalence of aspirin-induced asthma in Saudian asthmatic patients. Allergol Immunopathol (Madr). 2010;38(4):181-186.

11. Serra-Batlles JPlaza VMorejón EComella ABrugués J. Costs of asthma according to the degree of severity. Eur Respir J. 1998;12(6):1322-1326.

12. Lai  CKW,  Kim YY  Kuo  SH , Spencer M  Williams AE. Cost of asthma in the Asia-Pacific region. . Eur Respir Rev  2006; 15 (98) :10-16.

13. Masoli M,Fabian D,Holt S,Beasley R. Global Initiative for asthma(GINA) program: The global burden of asthma: executive summary of the GINA dissemination committee report .Allergy 2004,59(5):469-478.

14. Asthma in America: a landmark survey. Glaxosmithkline,1998. Available at: http://www.asthmainamerica.com. Accessed may 15, 2006.

15.Mohammadbeigi A,Hasaanzadeh JJ,Mousavizadeh AA. Prevalence of asthma in elementary school age children in Iran--a systematic review and meta analysis study.Pak J Biol Sci2011;14(19):887-893.

16. Entezari A, Mehrabi Y, Varesvazirian M, Pourpak Z, Moin M. A systematic review of recent asthma symptom surveys in Iranian children. Chron Respir Dis. 2009;6(2):109-14.

17.  Ghaffari J,  Mohammadzadeh I,  Khalilian  AR,   Rafatpanah H, Mohammadjafari  H,  Davoudi  A. Prevalence of asthma, allergic rhinitis and eczema in elementary schools in Sari (Iran).Caspian J Intern Med 2012; 3(1): 372-376.

 

18.Mohammadzadeh I,  Ghafari J,  Barari Savadkoohi R,  Tamaddoni A, Esmaeili Dooki MR, Alizadeh Navaei R. The Prevalence of Asthma, Allergic Rhinitis and Eczema in North of Iran: the International Study of Asthma and Allergies in Childhood (ISAAC). Iran J Pediatr 2008; 18 (2):117-122.

 

19. Felix H. Sennhauser, Charlotte Braun-Fahrla¨nder  , Johannes H. Wildhaber . The burden of asthma in children: a European perspective. PAEDIATRIC RESPIRATORY REVIEWS 2005; 6: 2–7.

20. Singh M.The burden of asthma in children:an Asian perspective. PAEDIATRIC RESPIRATORY REVIEWS 2005; 6: 14–19.

21. Pinto Pereira LM, Jackman J,Figaro, Babootee H, Cudjoe G, Farrell S, Francis-Regis C,  Garcia Henry K,  Pandor A,  Walters T,  Bekele I. Health burden of co-morbid asthma and allergic rhinitis in West Indian children.  Allergologia et Immunopathologia 2010;38(3):129–134.

22.  Chen YZ. National Cooperation Group on Childhood Asthma [A Nationwide survey in China on prevalence of asthma in urban children . Zhonghua Er Ke Za Zhi 2003; 41: 123–127.

 

23. The International Study of Asthma and Allergies in Childhood (ISAAC) Steering Committee. Worldwide variation in prevalence of symptoms of asthma, allergic rhino conjunctivitis, and atopic eczema The International Study of Asthma and Allergies in Childhood (ISAAC). Eur Respir J 1998; 12: 315–335.

 

24. Mocelin H, Fischer G, Longhi J et al. Analysis of paediatric asthma admissions in Porto Alegre. Brazil Eur Respir J 2002; 20: 147.

 

25. Santana J, Barreto S, Carvalho P. Factors related to severe acute asthma in childhood: epidemiological and clinical aspects. J Pediatr Rio J 1997; 73: 324–334.

 

26. Toelle BG, Peat JK, Mellis CM, Woolcock AJ. The cost of childhood asthma to Australian families. Pediatr Pulmonol 1995; 19:330-335.

 

27. Patrick W. Sullivan, PhDa, Vahram H. Ghushchyan, PhDb, Julia F. Slejko, BAb, Belozeroff, PhDc, Denise R. Globe, PhDc, Shao-Lee Lin, MD, PhDd.The burden of adult asthma in the United States: Evidence from the Medical Expenditure Panel Survey. Journal of Allergy and Clinical Immunology 2011;127(2):363–369.e3

28. Leanne M. Poulos, Brett G. Toelle, Guy B. Marks. The burden of asthma in children: an Australian perspective. Paediatric Respiratory Reviews 2005;6(1): 20–27.

 

29. Noronha M, Campos H. Hospitalizac¸o˜es por asma no Brasil. Pulma˜o RJ

2000; 9: 10–30.

 

30.   Lo´pez C, Ferguson K, Bermu´dez B, Salazar M. Asma infantile en el servicio de pediatria del Hospital Nacional Edgardo Rebagliati Martins. Ver Me´d Inst Peru Segur Soc 1993; 2: 51–55.

31. Stanley J. Szefler, MD, Robert S. Zeiger, MD, PhD, Tmirah Haselkorn, PhD, David R. Mink, MS§, Tripthi V. Kamath, PhD, James E. Fish, MD, , Bradley E. Chipps, MD. Economic burden of impairment in children with severe or difficult-to-treat asthma . Annals of Allergy, Asthma & Immunology 2011;107(2):110-119.

 

32. Holt S. In: The burden of asthma. Wellington: Asthma &Respiratory Foundation of New Zealand; 2001.

 

33. Singh RB. Asthma in India: Applying science to reality. Clin Exptl

Allergy 2004;34:686.

 

34. Stock S, Redaelli M, Luengen M, Wendland G, Civello D, Lauterbach KW. Asthma : prevalence and cost of illness. Eur Respir J 2005; 25(1):47-53.

35. Van Ganse E, Laforest L, Pietri G, et al. persistent asthma: disease control, resource utilization and direct costs.  Eur  Respir J 2002; ;20(2):260-7.

36. Bisgaard H, Gillies JMG. The effect of inhaled fluticasone proprionate in the treatment of young asthmatic children: a dose comparison study. Am J Respir Crit Care Med 1999; 160: 126–131.